Puzzle Finance Blog

It’s easier than you think to lose money on property

AT A time when first home buyers compete desperately to “win” at auction and investors fork out huge sums for homes close to the CBD, it’s easy to forget there are some genuinely terrible buys on the market.

It’s assumed that if you manage to get your foot on the property ladder then you have crossed over to the winning team and are now on a capital growth trajectory headed toward the skies.

However, according to Kiril Ruvinsky, who is the corporate partnerships director of Strategic Investment Group, it is very easy to lose money on property.

“The most common thing we hear from clients is that they bought a property 10 years ago in Queensland or elsewhere, and they have either lost money or experienced no capital growth,” Mr Ruvinsky said.

“We hear this all the time.”

So how are people managing to lose money on property?


The type of property has a lot to do with it. Apartments have not performed nearly as well as houses in recent years, and off-the-plan purchases are risky.

“You can end up buying an off-the-plan property and when it comes time to settle a few years later, the bank can value it at much less,” said investor and owner of Revolutionary Real Estate, David Kaity.
“You could lose your deposit or you may have to come up with the shortfall.” 

The wrong property type isn’t confined to off-the-plan purchases either. Many buyers think older blocks with fewer units are fail-proof, but they too can be bad buys.

Mr Ruvinsky said buyers should order strata reports and hire a lawyer to look into any special levies in the owners’ corporation, or they could face a rude shock.

“We were looking into an apartment for a buyer, which looked fine, but when we looked at the strata documents there was a levy of $3 million to fix extensive water damage, which would have cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars,” Mr Ruvinsky said.

It’s also tempting for buyers to overlook building and pest inspections — $1000 for every home you bid on adds up quickly — but Mr Ruvinsky said that a house with serious damage, such as rot caused by termites, was hard to spot from the outside and could cost tens of thousands to fix.


Be aware, too, of the type of title attached to the apartment. A strata title is the most common, but watch out for the thorny company title units, which are still present in Sydney’s Rushcutters Bay and Potts Point areas.

“They are cheaper because they are owned by a company you buy into, but they are harder to sell and they often have restrictions on how many apartments can be leased to tenants,” Mr Ruvinsky said. 

It’s worth noting, too, in Victoria there is a third class of title, called stratum, in which the apartment block is subdivided into lots.

Each unit owner owns their lot, but also holds shares in a service company, which manages the common property. These units are also usually worth less than strata title units and some banks won’t lend on them.


Often buyers will try and build equity by buying a cheap home, renovating it and flipping it for profit. Easy, right? Mr Kaity knows first-hand how fraught the process can be.

He nearly lost money on a renovation he did on a post-war, three-bedroom home in the Brisbane suburb of Camp Hill.

Mr Kaity and his wife spent six months researching home renovations and yet the couple still managed to commit the cardinal sin of DIY: over capitalising.

“We did a structural renovation instead of a cosmetic one and it was a lot of work,” he said.

“If we hadn’t decided to sell the property ourselves, we would have lost about $20,000.”

Mr Kaity made a few errors: he added a bedroom and bathroom, but he didn’t create a second living area, which was the trend among other large homes in the area.

“We have since gone on to renovate other homes successfully, but we learned a lot the first time,” he said.


Desperate first-timers often end up spending too much. If you happen to over pay at the top of the market and try and sell a few years later during a correction, you could be facing a loss.

Founder and CEO of Luxland Investments, Zah Azmi, said overpaying was the result of not enough research and letting emotion getting in the way.

“This can lead to over leveraging themselves and taking on too much debt, resulting in higher repayments that they can’t afford,” he said.

“If the deal falls over due to the seller wanting too much, then you should walk away.

“Being patient and moving on with the searching process will be beneficial in the long term.”


Finally, regional areas with little economic prospects or population growth and small towns in the midst of boom should sound alarm bells, according to Mr Kaity. 

“We have seen the mining towns in WA experience significant growth and then crash,” Mr Kaity said.

“A small town may boom because of an infrastructure project, but if that project is short-lived, and it’s a one-industry town, you could lose a lot of money when you go to sell.

“You need to be buying at the top of the bell curve: the place where most people are buying and selling.”

Johanna Leggatt is a Melbourne-based freelance journalist. Continue the conversation on Twitter @johannaleggatt

Posted by Johanna Leggatt - News Limited on 14th May, 2017 | Comments | Trackbacks | Permalink

Budget 2017: where first home buyers stand now – all the help and hits

In one of those worst-kept budget secrets, the government threw almost everything at the housing affordability crisis on Tuesday night. And it might just work. Not least because it feels like house price growth in some areas is already slowing

The headline news from the budget is the proposed new First Home Super Saver Scheme. Laudably resisting the temptation to allow people to raid their actual super for a home, this scheme would instead let them save explicitly into it for property – with similar tax perks.

So aspiring property owners would pay not their marginal rate but just the 15 per cent super contribution tax. They would be able to save $30,000 or $15,000 a year – each – so a couple can amass double (note this is subject to the overall annual concessional contributions limit, which includes the 9.5 per cent employers pay, of $25,000 a year).

This money will grow at the 90-day bank bill rate plus 3 per cent, which is a nice boost on what you can get in a traditional savings account. On withdrawal, this money will be taxed at the relevant marginal rate minus 30 per cent.  You can calculate to how much greater your deposit can grow here.

The Super Saver is a nice demand-side mechanism that, unlike grants and giveaways, should not directly inflate prices. It's also a better, more familiar proposition that Labor's previous and unpopular former First Home Saver Accounts.

But there's no point, literally, super-charging Australians' deposits if they remain a futile chase for rampaging prices. 

So it's with some relief to investors, often blamed for the rises, that largely they have been spared from a crackdown. Negative gearing stays with some small tweaks (you can forget the "inspection" trip to the Gold Coast and kiss goodbye to some depreciation items unless you actually bought them). Capital gains tax (CGT) concessions too are safe.

But it's a different story for overseas investors, where there's a deliberate campaign to cull.

·         The main residence exemption from CGT will disappear entirely for non- or temporary residents – effective immediately (although they can claim the exemption on existing properties until June 30, 2019).

·         Foreign ownership in new developments will be restricted to 50 per cent.

To boost the availability of rental accommodation, future foreign owners will also incur a $5000 "ghost tax" if they leave a property vacant for six or more months in a year. Meanwhile, local investors who offer cheaper rents to tenants on low to moderate incomes could qualify for extra CGT concessions, from 50 to 60 per cent (a registered community housing provider must manage the property for at least three years).

How to get more housing stock for sale though, the big issue for house prices? Australians 65 and over are going to be encouraged to downsize by the ability to shelter $300,000 – again, each person in a couple – within tax advantaged super (but note this would be fully assessed for pension purposes). There's talk this could release 50,000 homes onto the market. 

The government is also releasing surplus defence land on the outskirts of Melbourne, for 6000 new homes, and Commonwealth land in Western Sydney.

Of course, this is all on top of the concerted regulatory crackdown on investors and on interest-only loans to owner occupiers. The average amount lent for property, across investors and owner occupiers, began ticking down two months ago and now stands at levels of a year ago: $353,700. 

It's early days and there's a lot of talk the government has not gone far enough to fix housing affordability. But containing property prices is a delicate issue. Two out of three voters already own one.

Nicole Pedersen-McKinnon is a commentator and educator who presents her Smart Money Start , fun financial literacy incursion, in high schools around Australia. Follow Nicole on Facebook

Posted by Nicole Pedersoen-McKinnon - The Age on 10th May, 2017 | Comments | Trackbacks | Permalink

Puzzle Finance Blog

About Puzzle Finance


May 2017
March 2017
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
October 2016
July 2016
June 2016
May 2016
April 2016
March 2016
February 2016
January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
February 2013
January 2013
December 2012
November 2012
October 2012
September 2012
August 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010


Purchase or Rent (1)
The Age (1)

Recent Puzzle Finance Blog Posts

14 May 17: It’s easier than you think to lose money on property AT A time when first home buyers compete desperately to “win” at auction and investors fork out huge sums for homes close to the CBD, it’s easy to forg... [More...]
10 May 17: Budget 2017: where first home buyers stand now – all the help and hits In one of those worst-kept budget secrets, the government threw almost everything at the housing affordability crisis on Tuesday night. And it might just work... [More...]
10 Mar 17: How to spot a property spruiker Property is dominating the headlines, so anybody who can qualify for a loan appears to be trying to jump on the bandwagon. And of course, when any asset class... [More...]
10 Mar 17: Aussies in the dark as big changes loom for credit card, loan and mortgage applications NEW rules affecting every Australian applying for credit cards, loans or mortgages will soon kick in, but most people don’t even know about them. That... [More...]
7 Mar 17: When does it make sense to buy an apartment? There’s been plenty of talk recently about the dangers of buying an apartment – particularly those in large high-rise developments in the Melbourne, Sydne... [More...]
5 Mar 17: How to protect yourself from rising interest rates With lenders increasingly out of sync with the RBA , it’s no wonder people are feeling jittery about interest rates. Since their failure to pass on th... [More...]